Peer Review Policy
At DRAVIDIAN JOURNAL OF COMMERCE AND MANAGEMENT STUDIES, published by Dravidian Publication, we are committed to maintaining academic excellence and publication ethics. Our journal follows a Double-Blind Peer Review process in line with guidelines prescribed by ISSN, UGC-CARE, COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics), and other recognized indexing agencies.
Type of Peer Review
We follow the Double-Blind Peer Review model:
- The identities of authors and reviewers are kept confidential from each other.
- This process ensures impartiality, objectivity, and ethical assessment of scholarly work.
Peer Review Process Followed by Our Journal
a. Initial Editorial Screening
Each submission undergoes a preliminary check by the editorial board to assess:
- Relevance to the journal’s scope.
- Adherence to submission guidelines.
- Plagiarism using reliable detection tools.
Manuscripts not meeting these criteria are returned to the author without peer review.
b. Assignment to Reviewers
Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to two or more subject experts for evaluation. Reviewers are chosen based on their expertise, qualifications, and familiarity with the subject area.
c. Review Criteria
Reviewers assess submissions on:
- Originality and contribution to the field.
- Rigor and appropriateness of methodology.
- Clarity and coherence of argument.
- Referencing and academic writing quality.
- Ethical standards.
d. Editorial Decision
Based on reviewer feedback, the editorial board may decide to:
- Accept the manuscript (with or without minor revisions).
- Request major revisions and resubmission.
- Reject the manuscript with feedback.
The Editor-in-Chief/Managing Editor reserves the final decision authority.
Review Timelines
Acknowledgement of Submission: Within 3 working days
- Initial Editorial Review: Within 5–7 working days.
- Peer Review Duration: 3 to 4 weeks.
- Final Decision Communication: Within 6 to 8 weeks of submission.
Confidentiality and Ethics
- All manuscripts and reviewer comments are kept confidential.
- Reviewers must disclose any conflicts of interest and withdraw if necessary.
- The journals follow strict policies against plagiarism, data manipulation, and duplicate submissions.
Reviewer Recognition
Dravidian Publication appreciates the contribution of peer reviewers and offers:
- Certificates of Reviewing upon request.
- Annual acknowledgment (with reviewer consent).
- Opportunities for long-term collaboration with our editorial team.
Appeals and Complaints
Authors may appeal editorial decisions by submitting a written justification. All appeals are reviewed by the Senior Editorial Panel to ensure fairness and transparency.
Contact Us
For queries regarding our Peer Review Policy or to register as a reviewer, contact:
- managingeditor@dravidianpublication.com
- www.dravidianpublication.com
- Published by: Dravidianpublication